Maybelline to NYX Foundation Shade Guide
Find your NYX Can't Stop Won't Stop shade if you know your Maybelline Fit Me shade. Drugstore brand comparison.
Complete Shade Conversion Table
| Maybelline Shade | Depth | Undertone | NYX Match | Confidence |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 110 Porcelain | 1/12 | cool | Pale | exact |
| 115 Ivory | 2/12 | warm | Light Ivory | exact |
| 120 Classic Ivory | 2/12 | cool | Light Porcelain | exact |
| 125 Nude Beige | 3/12 | neutral | Light | exact |
| 128 Warm Nude | 3/12 | warm | Vanilla | exact |
| 130 Buff Beige | 4/12 | neutral | Natural | exact |
| 220 Natural Beige | 5/12 | warm | Medium Olive | exact |
| 222 True Beige | 5/12 | neutral | True Beige | exact |
| 228 Soft Tan | 6/12 | warm | Classic Tan | exact |
| 230 Natural Buff | 6/12 | neutral | Medium Buff | exact |
| 232 Light Honey | 7/12 | warm | Golden Honey | exact |
| 235 Pure Beige | 7/12 | cool | Golden Honey | approximate |
| 238 Rich Tan | 7/12 | warm | Golden Honey | exact |
| 310 Sun Beige | 8/12 | warm | Warm Caramel | exact |
| 320 Natural Tan | 8/12 | neutral | Mahogany | exact |
| 330 Toffee | 9/12 | warm | Warm Mahogany | exact |
| 332 Golden Caramel | 10/12 | warm | Sienna | exact |
| 335 Classic Tan | 10/12 | neutral | Deep Walnut | exact |
| 338 Spicy Brown | 11/12 | warm | Mocha | exact |
| 340 Cappuccino | 12/12 | warm | Deep Espresso | exact |
How We Match Shades
Our shade matching system works by comparing two key properties of each foundation shade:
Shade Depth
Each shade is mapped to a universal depth scale from 1 (very fair) to 12 (very deep). Shades with the same depth number are the closest match.
Undertone
We match warm, cool, neutral, and olive undertones. An exact undertone match plus same depth gives the highest confidence rating.
Confidence Ratings
Want more precise matching?
Use our full Foundation Shade Matcher to compare across all 13+ brands, or take the Skin Tone Finder quiz first.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is NYX a good alternative to Maybelline?
NYX (Can't Stop Won't Stop Foundation) offers comparable shade coverage to Maybelline (Fit Me Matte + Poreless). Both brands provide shades across a wide range of depths and undertones. The best match depends on your specific shade — check the table above for your conversion.
Why doesn't my Maybelline shade have an exact match in NYX?
Not all brands use the same depth/undertone combinations. If your shade shows "close" or "approximate", it means NYX doesn't have a shade with the exact same depth + undertone, but the suggested match is the nearest available option.
Should I go lighter or darker if the match is approximate?
If the match is approximate, we recommend testing the suggested shade in natural daylight. If it looks slightly off, try one shade lighter for a more natural look or one shade darker for more coverage. Many stores in India (like Nykaa, Sephora) offer testers.
How accurate is this shade matching?
Our matching system uses a universal depth (1-12) and undertone (warm/cool/neutral) scale to map shades across brands. "Exact" matches are typically very accurate. "Close" matches are good starting points. Always test on your jawline in natural light for the best result.